City Island, New York hotel rooms at the Preferred

"Went for a long weekend. Patty at front desk was amazing managed to book us in early. Was very pleasant and professional. Room was clean and comfortable. "

"Extremely pleased with my stay at the lovely New Yorker! In town for shows at MSG and Broadway and the location was perfect—walkable! Appreciated feeling very safe with staff and security. My Only issue was there was not wifi connection in my room, so I was unable to research the city as needed on my phone or relax with television at night. "

"Great service "

"Very clean and great location, staff very lovely "

"Love it"

"The staff was so kind and helpful. We had kids with us and they were kind to them as well."

"We had an amazing time. The property is elegant and full of amenities with quick access to transportation. "

"This was a very pleasant experience for us. The room (King) was spacious and the bed was SUPER comfortable! When we requested items for our room (fridge and towels) they arrived within minutes. The fridge is an extra fee ($25 for the entire stay), but we knew that going into it and we had items that had to stay cold. It was worked into the cost of the stay but we each got a $30/day credit to use at the on site restaurants or bar, so it was the illusion of free stuff! I was quite satisfied and would stay here again. "

"Absolutely loved staying here. From check in we received the best customer service. Our room was not quite ready and we did not mind,the beautiful Erica provided us with a basket of goodies to apologise for our troubles.The grab and go breakfast was perfect. Loved the historical feel of the hotel and security was paramount. Quiet rooms, clean and brilliant locations. 30 sec walk to times square and staff informative. Cant wait to come back"